- Beyond Blue Forums
- People like me
- Multicultural experiences
- Difficulty in distinguishing between casual racism...
- Subscribe to RSS Feed
- Mark Topic as New
- Mark Topic as Read
- Pin this Topic for Current User
- Get Updates for this Discussion
- Printer Friendly Page
Difficulty in distinguishing between casual racism and a neutral comment
- Mark as New
- Follow Post
- Mute
- Subscribe to RSS Feed
- Permalink
- Report Post
My father became an Australian citizen in his 20s during his studies; so I was an Australian citizen by descent when I was born. However, I was born and raised overseas until I was 13 years old and then I moved to Australia. I can speak English clearly most of the time when I am not tired or nervous, but I still have a foreign accent (as described by some people I have encountered over the past 9 years in Australia).
Over the past 9 years, I have noticed that if I do not speak much, some people naturally assume that I do not speak or understand English well. I was in a seminar and there was a Mandarin translation service. After the seminar, an acquaintance at the time asked me whether the headphones worked properly. At the moment, I wondered whether it was because I looked Chinese to him (whom I had barely spoken with a week before the seminar) and that means I do not understand English? By the way, Chinese is a nationality and there are 56 ethnic groups in China.
I gave 2 talks which were great according to the audience; however, both times after the talk, an acquaintance I have known for ~3 years said perfect or great English as a compliment. I said to myself, so an East Asian looking person or someone with a foreign accent does not generally speak English well? which is a speculation of mine. One time someone on the street thought I looked "Vietnamese" and said "hello" to me in Vietnamese as he explained. Another person I met for the first time at a train station was impressed by my English after he found out that I was born and raised overseas. Even friends (not close) asked me how could I speak good English because "many" "Chinese" people they know do not speak English as good as I do, or they said something similar to that.
There are more experiences similar to the above examples. They all asked me "where are you from (originally)?" at some point. I sometimes struggle to answer that question because I do not know what they actually mean by "originally". I have been an Australian citizen since I was born in East Asia, so I am actually from Australia and East Asia? Or should I answer where I was born?
I believe people who asked those questions or made those comments did not mean to offend anyone. They simply have not had many multicultural interactions in their lives due to all sort of reasons, or they are trying to be nice by making a compliment.
However, I could not help but feel self-conscious because even today I still have similar experiences.
- Mark as New
- Follow Post
- Mute
- Subscribe to RSS Feed
- Permalink
- Report Post
Hi Donte'
Very interesting and true to life observation! This is certainly something that I witness all the time in my community, there is certainly some type of interracial element alive.
In my community I believe that social and political set up is the reason, Lebanon was founded and continues to operate on a confessional system, you only get financial and other civil supports depending on your religion, region and residential numbers. This system has created division but in some ways it has created unity in that people of each region/ village/ political sect etc will band together.
Like you, when I am meeting fellow Lebanese here in Australia they ask which region of Lebanon am I from? Certainly on most occasions, learning where I am from has actually been a positive warm experience.
I have found that it can depend on the personal interaction, how you communicate and what people already know about you as a person but even with this, you are so right when you say that there is interracial behaviour at play and not every experience is positive.
In the peer support ground project that we deliver, the team and I encounter this all time. We cannot coordinate group support sessions with some certain cultural groups of the same country and background because they refuse to mix.
Hayfa
- Mark as New
- Follow Post
- Mute
- Subscribe to RSS Feed
- Permalink
- Report Post
Hi Donte
I had similar experiences.
Some of my friends, classmates, and teachers from high school had called me by my friends' names who were
Everyone who had mistaken my name knew me for a while before they met my friends who were possibly of East Asian heritage based on their appearance. All of them eventually got my name right; some took almost 2 years.
I felt sorry for them because they were embarrassed when they finally
I have a Chinese name and an English name. Most people know me by my English name. I may have a strange
Interesting fact: none of my friends with an East Asian appearance and/or heritage have ever called me by another mutual friend's name.
Regards
Rob13579
- Mark as New
- Follow Post
- Mute
- Subscribe to RSS Feed
- Permalink
- Report Post
Hi Rob,
Thank you for sharing your experience. I only have one name but it is a well-known name in English and people still get it wrong! I can only imagine the confusion of having two names and one in a different language!
It's good that you can empathize and smile. That's a good approach. 🙂
- Mark as New
- Follow Post
- Mute
- Subscribe to RSS Feed
- Permalink
- Report Post
There are currently Community discussion sessions on the development of the Victorian Government's Anti-Racism Action Plan.
These sessions are open to public if anyone would like to consider attending.
The Multicultural Affairs and Social Cohesion Division, Department of Premier and Cabinet, invites everyone to these community discussions on the development of the Victorian Government's Anti-Racism Action Plan.
The Victorian Government committed to the development of an Anti-Racism Action Plan as part of the Multicultural Policy Statement,Victorian. And Proud Of It.. launched last year,
They want to hear from people across communities and organisations about how racism and race-based discrimination is experienced by communities, and your thoughts on their proposed approach.
You can find out about times and locations for community discussions here: https://multicultural.vic.gov.au/projects-and-initiatives2/anti-racism-action-plan
More information on the Multicultural Policy Statement is available here: https://proud.vic.gov.au/wp-content/uploads/2017/02/Victorian-And-Proud-of-it-MPS-180207.pdf
- Mark as New
- Follow Post
- Mute
- Subscribe to RSS Feed
- Permalink
- Report Post
Hi Donte’,
Thank you so much for letting everyone know 🙂 I think it’s good that the Victorian govt. wants to get people involved.
Pepper xoxo
- « Previous
- Next »
- Anxiety
- BB Social Zone
- Depression
- Grief and loss
- Multicultural experiences
- PTSD and trauma
- Relationship and family issues
- Sexuality and gender identity
- Staying well
- Suicidal thoughts and self-harm
- Supporting family and friends
- Treatments, health professionals, therapies
- Welcome and orientation
- Young people