- Beyond Blue Forums
- Mental health conditions
- Depression
- Re: Why can’t i cry?
- Subscribe to RSS Feed
- Mark Topic as New
- Mark Topic as Read
- Pin this Topic for Current User
- Follow
- Printer Friendly Page
Why can’t i cry?
- Mark as New
- Follow Post
- Mute
- Subscribe to RSS Feed
- Permalink
- Report Post
I haven’t cried in just over a year and the last time i did was during a funeral. I feel like every time i feel like crying there is no tears that come out and i just cannot cry. i want to know what is wrong with me?
- Mark as New
- Follow Post
- Mute
- Subscribe to RSS Feed
- Permalink
- Report Post
'There is a sacredness in tears. They are not the mark of weakness put of power. They speak more eloquently than ten thousand tongues. They are the messengers of overwhelming grief, of deep contrition and of unspeakable love.' - Washington Irving
Hi odium
The above quote is one of my favourite quotes, where Washington Irving expresses tears as being the result of extreme emotion. While some people will only cry under extreme circumstances, some will cry with even the slightest emotion. Others may never cry or even have a condition that doesn't allow them to produce tears. I suppose, at the end of the day, the question becomes about what is normal for us.
Not sure if it will help but I'll throw out the following in case it does
- While I will cry/vent my extreme sadness, when I'm feeling a sense of grief, loss or disappointment, once I have moved through it I may no longer cry or be able to cry, once that process is complete
- While some deeply feeling aspect of me comes to life, I can cry at the drop of a hat. If the pure analyst in me is analysing something that appears overwhelmingly upsetting, I cannot cry while in a state of pure analysis. It's a matter of purely observing what's upsetting, rather than feeling what's upsetting
- As someone who can easily feel so deeply for others, to the point where it can lead me to sob uncontrollably at times, I can feel their overwhelming grief. if I have little emotional connection to someone I may not cry for them. If I have some resentment towards them for some reason and a deep disconnection from them, it is impossible for me to cry for them. At a recent funeral, I discretely went outside for 5 minutes before returning. I just couldn't manage the overwhelming volume of grief in the room
- I've found it takes a certain amount of energy to be able to feel emotion. If I have no energy, for one reason or another, all I may feel is numb or emotionally detached
I think moving through different stages can be another factor. For example, there may be the stage of making sense of what's incredibly upsetting, where there may be few to no tears. The next stage may involve an outpouring of tears on and off for days, weeks or months. Then, when that process of venting has come to a close, the next stage may involve talking it out with someone, so as to begin moving forward in the best direction. So, the stages may involve figuring it out, crying it out and then talking it out. It all gradually comes out in a process.
I imagine there is good reason for you not being able to cry. Can be so challenging to find the reasons for why we work the way we do at times.
- Mark as New
- Follow Post
- Mute
- Subscribe to RSS Feed
- Permalink
- Report Post
Dear odium,
When I was 19 I went for at least a year being unable to cry at all. In my case it linked with a situation from the previous year that had been very stressful for me. It was an unresolved situation that left me in a kind of stuck/frozen limbo state. I had always cried easily in the past but now couldn’t cry at all, even though I desperately needed to. But the ability to cry did come back.
So I’m wondering if it’s just a stage you are going through for one reason or another? Is there some aspect of your life you feel stuck in or that hasn’t resolved? You don’t have to reveal what that is here if there is something. I just wondered if that might be the case?
Sometimes working with a therapist/counsellor can help to identify where the inability to cry is coming from and, if it’s a good working relationship that feels safe, it can also be a place where the tears finally come.
The situation I went through in my late teenage years I also felt I could not really share or discuss with anyone. I think that kept the tears from coming as well. I just want to reassure you that the ability to cry can definitely return. As The Rising mentions there can be different stages we go through, some where tears don’t come and some where the tears come readily.
Tears can be very healing. Sometimes we just need a safe space for them to come out. I find other people being kind to me is something that can induce tears, or watching a very moving film. But I do know that experience of going for a long time without tears. I think it’s sometimes just what our body does when we are emotionally stuck in some way, but the stuckness will release again in time.