- Beyond Blue Forums
- Caring for myself and others
- Treatments, health professionals and therapies
- Magnesium and Depression
- Subscribe to RSS Feed
- Mark Topic as New
- Mark Topic as Read
- Pin this Topic for Current User
- Follow
- Printer Friendly Page
Magnesium and Depression
- Mark as New
- Follow Post
- Mute
- Subscribe to RSS Feed
- Permalink
- Report Post
Hi!
I have recently read a few articles on magnesium as a supplement to treat depression. I am keen to try any natural alternatives to ADs and planning to speak to the Psychiatrist about it on my next visit.
In the meantime I would be interested to hear from anyone who might have had some experience with magnesium supplements - did it make a difference? Any side effects? Any views and opinions would be appreciated.
Look forward to any comments.
Regards
K
- Mark as New
- Follow Post
- Mute
- Subscribe to RSS Feed
- Permalink
- Report Post
hi there Hideaway
i was on magnesium for a while and didnt find that it helped with my anxiety or depression it did however help with muscle cramps.
im not sure is a psychiatrsit would be able to help you with natural alternatives but seeing a naturopath might
- Mark as New
- Follow Post
- Mute
- Subscribe to RSS Feed
- Permalink
- Report Post
As a medical practitioner , you get asked a lot of questions about alternative therapies and whether they work . The alternative therapy industry is a huge multi billion dollar industry and they use their dollars in lots of campaigns that encourage people to take supplements for all sorts of things that have no proven scientific basis.
In fact they often encourage healthy people with normal diets to take supplements too ( I see these ads on the TV all the time!)
So its super hard for the medical profession to compete against all that marketing and get it though to people that almost all supplements have NO rational basis for use.
Now of course some people do really need a supplement e.g. , if you are Iron deficient and need Iron , or pregnant women really need certain supplements to help reduce risk of neural tube defects. However, unless you have a diagnosed or proven reason to take them , most supplements are simply excreted by the urinary system ( that means you have very costly urine !)
So.. is there evidence for Magnesium use in depression? Or is it just a case of costly urine ?
As things stand, the jury is still out on this. I haven’t seen reports of trials to prove the link that taking Magnesium will treat depression.
Now , of course it may be that
1. There is that trial in existence somewhere but I haven’t seen it
2. It may be about to be proven , but the info just isn’t available yet
3. That it may not work in theory, but for one individual it works and they swear by it.
I would say to a patient who wants to try it, that as long as it doesn’t interfere with other medications and they take the recommended dose , there is no harm in trying it , but they will probably get better results from things like exercise and mindfulness which have been better studied recently and shown to be helpful.
By the way , BB does have a pamphlet that covers all the alternative stuff for everyone to check out.
A guide to what works for depression
- Mark as New
- Follow Post
- Mute
- Subscribe to RSS Feed
- Permalink
- Report Post
- Mark as New
- Follow Post
- Mute
- Subscribe to RSS Feed
- Permalink
- Report Post
- Mark as New
- Follow Post
- Mute
- Subscribe to RSS Feed
- Permalink
- Report Post
- Mark as New
- Follow Post
- Mute
- Subscribe to RSS Feed
- Permalink
- Report Post
- Mark as New
- Follow Post
- Mute
- Subscribe to RSS Feed
- Permalink
- Report Post
I see in Dr Kim's post that she is saying exercise and mindfulness should be looked into, so hardly rejecting thousands of years of wisdom. You can't get more natural than physical activity and meditation. And she also said in her post that if you wanted to give magnesium a go, then by all means do it, but be aware that the evidence for whether or not it works is limited. I would suggest that if you find that advice unhelpful, then you are a little closed minded.
Unfortunately some people are so convinced that they know best that they won't listen to doctors, who have trained for years to know what works and what doesn't. I am happy to trust mine, but I understand that some people are yet to find a doctor they can trust, and that is a sad thing.
- Mark as New
- Follow Post
- Mute
- Subscribe to RSS Feed
- Permalink
- Report Post
Hi after being struct by depression and anxiety for 20 years, I am willing to give anything a try! How much magnesium is a a good dose.
Thanks
- Mark as New
- Follow Post
- Mute
- Subscribe to RSS Feed
- Permalink
- Report Post
hi tassietassie and welcome
On suppliment packaging itll have directions and dosages on there or consult your gp as they might be able to reccomend a specific dose for you. each person and brand is different so its best to get some professional advice, sometimes pharmacists are really handy when it comes to this sort of thing too.
best of luck
- Mark as New
- Follow Post
- Mute
- Subscribe to RSS Feed
- Permalink
- Report Post
I was just reading this post with interest after reading an article recently about magnesium being used as an effective treatment for depression.
I notice that everyone seemed to be looking at oral magnesium supplementation. Wondering if anyone had tried transdermal instead. A daily bath with some magnesium chloride flakes or sprays of magnesium oil ?
Many articles say that we absorb mag better through our skin than our gut.
I’d be interested to hear whether anyone had tried magnesium in the bath and helped an episode of depression?