FAQ

Find answers to some of the more frequently asked questions on the Forums.

Forums guidelines

Our guidelines keep the Forums a safe place for people to share and learn information.

So, is it your illness or your personality?

white knight
Community Champion
Community Champion

What if we didn't have any mind troubles? What daily/weekly issues would we still have lingering that annoy us about ourselves?

Sometimes we can observe our relatives to find an answer. Eating disorders come to mind. Some of us can come to a conclusion that it is "our mental illness" when maybe obesity runs in the family. Moods could be the same. I'm on a hefty dose of mood stabiliser as is two of my blood relatives yet moodiness runs in the family....trouble is bipolar 2 and depression also run in the family and this can be a basis for bad moods or swings. This is just examples of my confusion about the topic as I'm not an expert.

Sometimes we grapple at things. I have a relative. She has heavy depression and moods. She told me in front of her younger sister, that she tells her sister all the time about her moods, its like she has 5 houses and every day she could be in any one of those 5 houses....5 different moods. My answer to that was...well if you think that's bad for you, not knowing which mood you'll be in, imagine what its like for your sister?

My point here is, insight is a gift for some of us. If you have insight you are one of the lucky ones. But insight into what is part of your mental condition compared to what would be there if you didn't have such condition would clarify so much and take away a lot of "circling around our problems"...indeed focussing on shadows while we could be putting all our energies into the real issues.

Consider this: For several years since my first visit to a psychiatrist I was always, for most of my then 47 years in fact, thinking I was the one and only ultra sensitive highly emotional person in my extended blood family. Last November I visited this part of the family interstate for the first time. My parents had split from them when I was a toddler so I hadn't met these people before. To my surprise my sensitive side and the emotional side responsible for some heavy and deep poetry over many years was mirrored by others in the family. One was an entertainer, the other an artist, one a writer and finally one was a WW2 veteran. The war veteran had fought at Kokoda and I'd heard about his battles with mental illness. I, like others put it down to the war...apparently not so, he was much like that prior to the war.

My message in this is try to be factual. Talk about these to your doctor/psychiatrist if you are concerned because by discounting some of your "hunches" it could help your recovery.

Tony WK

1 Reply 1

Elizabeth CP
Blue Voices Member
Blue Voices Member

Some of what you have discussed is the nature versus nurture argument. Is this due to my nature, genetics etc so my aunt was like this so I've inherited it. Or is it the environment the way you were brought up and experiences you have had. I suggest it is both. There does seem to be genetic links to mental illnesses but things which happen to you during your life play a huge part  We can't change our DNA but things can be done to limit the damage done by life stresses eg early intervention and support for at risk parents to decrease the risk of their children being exposed to abuse or neglect etc. Obviously that is only one very small example of what can be done. 

For those of us with mental health issues does it matter where it came from. It is more important learning to deal with it.

You mentioned having sensitive & artistic relatives. I think we would all benefit from learning to accept who we are including our talents and idiosyncrasies with the help of our therapists if required. Part of accepting your uniqueness is looking at the positive side. eg rather than thinking I'm sensitive therefore I'm no good, accept I'm sensitive so hanging around with people who like to pull people down is not a good idea but being sensitive means I'm more in tune with others feelings so I can help them or I can use my ability to imagine how others feel and use that in writing or other creative pursuits. A person with OCD tendencies may be much better in a job were everything needs to be kept in order and clean, neat & tidy compared to someone like me who is not so meticulous. My point is use your insight into yourself to make life choices which suit your characteristics and allow them to be used in a positive way rather than fighting them to be someone you aren't