- Beyond Blue Forums
- Caring for myself and others
- Relationship and family issues
- Narcissist the label
- Subscribe to RSS Feed
- Mark Topic as New
- Mark Topic as Read
- Pin this Topic for Current User
- Follow
- Printer Friendly Page
Narcissist the label
- Mark as New
- Follow Post
- Mute
- Subscribe to RSS Feed
- Permalink
- Report Post
Nowhere it seems more common than USA where people claim someone is a narcissist. Anything that evolves there, comes here quite quickly now with social media and internet influences.
I read recently a question from a member of an international forum - "My narcissist boyfriend has gone silent for 2 weeks, does that mean it's over?"
What followed was numerous answers all centreing on all actions a narcissist does, like using the silent treatment as a weapon, manipulation and grandiose reflections of themselves. Yet no one asked what actions the man labelled a narcissist actually did to deserve that label apart from having no contact for 2 weeks. Was the man using silence/absenteeism as a weapon or was he needing a break from a toxic relationship? Was he batheing in confidence or does he have a narcissist grandiosity demeanor? Does he manipulate or does he over suggest things due to not giving enough feedback?
Google "narcissist meaning" there is 9 signs of one-
Nine Signs and Symptoms of Narcissism
Grandiosity. Exaggerated sense of self-importance. ...
Excessive need for admiration. ...
Superficial and exploitative relationships. ...
Lack of empathy. ...
Identity disturbance. ...
Difficulty with attachment and dependency. ...
Chronic feelings of emptiness and boredom. ...
Vulnerability to life transitions
I'd suggest most people claiming their partner is a narcissist, wont satisfy most of these symptoms. So the label is overused, inflammatory and unjust... bullying.
E.g. A woman marries a guy that, later on has proved he is (in her eyes- lazy, looks in the mirror hourly, need constant praise, doesn't show empathy for her struggles and relies on her career success for financial stability. They have had 3 kids and just separated.... He exercises his rights to 50% custody which is opposite of her desire of full custody.
His partner labels him a narcissist. He loosely fits some of the 9 signs, enough for her to justify it.
Little did anyone realise that HIS symptoms also mirrored depression, lack of confidence from a poor upbringing, stares at the mirror because he has social barriers, feels shame and has a loud voice. Friends believe her.
That example might draw a long bow but claims by many that a narcissist is one when they are not is also a long bow...even longer!
The message here is evidence, if not presented to endorse the label someone uses...It's likely a gross exaggeration. Best not to fall for others claim someone is narcissistic imo.
TonyWK
- Mark as New
- Follow Post
- Mute
- Subscribe to RSS Feed
- Permalink
- Report Post
Well said Juliet
I also read today again on an international forum "what I did with my narcissistic wife when she gave me the silent treatment for 3 weeks is ...I gave it back to her for 4 weeks.
Two wrongs don't make a right. If you are not a narcissist then don't act like one. If you are treated inhumanely by a person urge them to get help. If they don't get help then take action to rid your life of such torturous behaviour.
"But labeling someone else with a psychological diagnosis that hasn’t been given by a medical professional may be considered a manipulative behavior in itself."
Very good comment. Often occurs when someone want to benefit from a situation.
TonyWK
- Mark as New
- Follow Post
- Mute
- Subscribe to RSS Feed
- Permalink
- Report Post
- Mark as New
- Follow Post
- Mute
- Subscribe to RSS Feed
- Permalink
- Report Post
I don't know the percentages but people who's depression is caused or triggered by a partners adverse behaviour must be high.
Gaslighting, silent treatment often is not realised by the victim as being abnormal. The perpetrator convinces the victim they are wrong.
Many patients attend therapy not because they are mentally unwell but because they are victims of abuse.
TonyWK
- Mark as New
- Follow Post
- Mute
- Subscribe to RSS Feed
- Permalink
- Report Post
- Mark as New
- Follow Post
- Mute
- Subscribe to RSS Feed
- Permalink
- Report Post
Hello Tony, Juliet...and all...🤗..
The silent treatment...If I even tried to give it back to my late husband...I had some very bad consequences coming my way.....I tried once...and that was one time too many...Strange how after weeks of totally ignoring you..They can start talking to you again...like they did nothing wrong and that period of their silence never even happened..
I think that they give the silent treatment because they know they are wrong and cannot tolerate that so they just close their mouth, ears and eyes..and make us invisible to them...Such a horrible feeling for the recipient....
Tony...I think that depression can be triggered by a person’s adverse behaviour towards a spouse/partner/parents/siblings etc......while still living with them....but once free from them....and the trauma they went through has caused a type of mental damage...then it seems to change into getting triggered into PTSD which is then followed by bad depression...
I think a lot of people have narcissistic traits and it will surface at times...and then they are called a narcissist..If these people seek help from professionals that is so good..but in my own opinion a true narcissist won’t reach out to professionals because..they believe nothing is wrong with them...they are right in everything they do and say...and everyone else is wrong...
Just my thoughts and not intending to hurt anyone reading...If I did I am really sorry..
Grandy..
- Mark as New
- Follow Post
- Mute
- Subscribe to RSS Feed
- Permalink
- Report Post
Hi Grandy and Juliet,
The meaning of the word narcissist or narcissistic has changed.
I saw a graph on the internet and prior to 1990 it was rarely used.
Furthermore, the unofficial meaning has changed. Here is the official meaning-
of, relating to, or characterized by narcissism: such as. a : extremely self-centered with an exaggerated sense of self-importance : marked by or characteristic of excessive admiration of or infatuation with oneself a narcissistic personality He was a very narcissistic man, not too concerned with the world.—
No mention.of the traits we think, like silent treatment, control, abuse, ownership and obsession.
Anyway, back to the now genericly known and accepted meaning.
Grandy you are right, a narc won't seek help. My theory on this is that while living their life of control few people can confront them and win. To bow to treatment is to risk their shield from cracking and give their victims a sniff of success or at least relevance.
Juliet- yes they are selfish, extremely which means they have little ability to truly love.As I see it the only way they will be caught out or condemned is shaming in a movement from the masses. The "me to" movement is an example, however that is where physical abuse was present which is, by courts (and juries) greater evidence. The narc can claim his/her silence was his human and constitutional right, his control of his spouse due to her need for it etc
Stamping it out impossible, freeing yourself from it, more ideal as that takes your power back.
My mother has narc traits. She ruined my 1st wedding 1985. By 2011 we were going ok but the attention wasn't on her when I was about to marry again so she wanted to ruin it again. I sort a AVO to ensure she couldn't attend our park wedding.
When I attended court the magistrate was about to read a letter from my mother. I requested he not do so. I knew what was in it e.g. my father would roll over in his grave etc etc.
He granted the AVO. We had a great wedding.
My mother's power neutralized.
TonyWK
- Mark as New
- Follow Post
- Mute
- Subscribe to RSS Feed
- Permalink
- Report Post
The term Narcissist does get thrown around a lot now
People who are true narcissists are few and far between from what I understand... that said, I'm sure many people have narcissistic tendencies. More often I now hear the abbreviated form of the word - "Narc". It's become a real throwaway word.
There's also so many different types of narcissist such as overt, covert and vulnerable... and then there is also borderline personality disorder.
The thing that makes me uncomfortable is the way people seem to vilify individuals who may be in the narcissist 'spectrum'. As if they are intrinsically horrible people. A lot of the time it can be the result of factors outside their control... upbringing etc.
My partner, she is on this spectrum. Several of my psychologists have suggested she is a covert narcissist or vulnerable narcissist. Initially I didn't believe it but further reading really opened my eyes. It explained so much about the confusing and erratic behaviour I was dealing with.
I wish people would be a bit more informed before using the "N" word so quickly.
- Mark as New
- Follow Post
- Mute
- Subscribe to RSS Feed
- Permalink
- Report Post
Hi Batticus
Extremely well written easily understood post.
We all know that many people with a undiagnosed mental illness won't seek help due to either denial or stubbornness. Narcissists or BPD sufferers are more likely not to seek treatment and if they do it's for short periods then they could blame the therapist or anyone else for being at fault.
However they all deserve equality of assistance but only that can be delivered to them if they are willing to receive it. Those that do face their demons deserve great respect and admiration. Those that don't will find life as being lonely as others around them drift away.
So yes "narc" the label is a savage word.
TonyWK
- Mark as New
- Follow Post
- Mute
- Subscribe to RSS Feed
- Permalink
- Report Post
Hi all,
I may be wrong but as I undestand it NPD is a personality disorder in one of the three clusters of personality disorders.
Some ppl don't believe that it exists, but it would be in the DSM
Is it a real thing? I don't know....
I find learning about narcissm as a whole pretty interesting, i used to always think it was a buzz word, but there are ppl who manifest the traits quite clearly. They are in every job and every walk of life. There are narc therapists, doctors, CEOs etc.
I had a narc therapist and my life was damaged beyond repair - it was terrible. But I have learnt a lot about how to spot the traits.
I agree the term is overused, but anyone who's experienced narc abuse would find it helpful to learn more about it. Can be a bit of an "aha" moment. For me the entitlement is a common theme with narcs in my life
- Mark as New
- Follow Post
- Mute
- Subscribe to RSS Feed
- Permalink
- Report Post
That's interesting.
Ive met many ppl with BPD in therapy though who do seek help.