FAQ

Find answers to some of the more frequently asked questions on the Forums.

Forums guidelines

Our guidelines keep the Forums a safe place for people to share and learn information.

How do I learn to forgive my brother's betrayal during mum's cancer treatment

David35
Community Member

Several years ago, mum got bladder cancer. She ultimately survived but the journey for the next few years was incredibly stressful. I live with mum, so I'm a carer somewhat too. During this time, my elder brother and his wife virtually stopped talking to us. He used to ring every week, then it was every few months. His wife stopped talking altogether. Throughout this period I suffered several mental breakdowns as a result of the ongoing stress with no support, bearing in mind my dad had died of cancer in 2016. At times, I was even mocked and made fun of for struggling to cope, such was the lack of empathy for me. I eventually got counseling with several counsellors and charities to help get me better.

But the general consensus was that I had developed a panic disorder and mild PTSD as a result of the relentless stress I was under to both look after mum's physical and mental health all by myself. As such there is now a massive gulf in the relationship between my brother and mum and I. He never once bothered to ask how I was doing and his wife has never once asked how mum was going. At the height of mum's treatment he was more concerned about what financial handouts he could get from mum rather than supporting either of us. His response to all of this was that "I have my own family."

So my question is, given that he is trying to make amends, and given that he won't accept any criticisms we make of him, how does anyone forgive someone for this behaviour? We no longer see his kids (maybe once a year if we're lucky), no longer get any updates, pictures, news, etc. It's like we are problems not people. The last few years have been so stressful, not just because of mum's cancer treatment, but the amount of stress they have incoporated into both our lives because we both had the expectations that he would be there for us, and he simply turned his back on us. How does someone cope with this?

48 Replies 48

David35
Community Member

Well a week later and still no response. It wasnt abusive, more a plea to let us back into his life. I still have anger issues and hurt that I was treated this way, which causes a strain on my relationship with mum. I honestly don't know what to do anymore. I've tried journaling. The sad part is that if he were to say sorry I'd let him back into my life tomorrow. But a good friend told me there's a difference between loving someone and trusting them. I love my bro, I just don't trust him anymore, with mum or me. And that is the most painful reality to accept. My faith says I should forgive him, but how if he's not remorseful or even talking to me.

I think a part of me is grieving the old version of him. But the police force has made him cynical, bitter, distrusting, etc. And the more he let's me down, the more I miss dad. He's like a rock that I went to sit on, only for it to crumble beneath me. As I get older there are medical things I would like to share with him, but know deep down he wouldn't be interested. It's a very isolating feeling. I don't hate him. I just wish my mental decline hadn't been caused by trusting someone who I admired and loved so much and turned out to be so incredibly selfish.

 

The rising,

I think that is what I must do. Accept him for who is. I don't like how his values have changed. It angers me to realise how he has treated us. But I know deep in my heart that until I do, I'll never be content in my life.

therising
Valued Contributor
Valued Contributor

Hi David

 

Can be such a hard thing to accept, the changes in someone. With their experiences shaping them or reforming them, we can be up against it.

 

While some experiences will bring out the best in people, other experiences will bring out parts that aren't necessarily all that good under certain circumstances. For example, someone could be a deeply feeling person before they start a certain job. As they go along through that job, it can develop the pure analyst in them. 'What strategy gets the best results? What is the most logical thing to do? What promotes the greatest level of efficiency? What do I need to become intolerant of, in order to get the job done?' and so on. So, over time, they can go from being deeply feeling to purely analytical. While they can become incredibly switched on in their job through developing greater strategy, logic, efficiency and intolerance, they can become switched off emotionally in some cases.

 

I think the parts of us that we come to develop the most begin to 'speak' to us in certain ways. No, it's not about hearing voices, simply about a change in our inner dialogue or the words that come to mind. The analyst in us (which can be good at helping us analyse time and time management) may dictate 'You don't have time for that person'. The intolerant part of us may insist 'You shouldn't have to tolerate that person's nature'. On the other hand, we might hear a deeply compassionate part of us insisting 'You need to find time and come to better understand why the person you once cared about is suffering so much'. At times, I think the part of parts of us that we're listening to the most (the inner dialogue we're taking the most notice of) will in some ways dictate our perspective and our actions.

I think I'm grieving the person I thought my brother was, rather than the person he actually is. Reconciling those two versions in my mind takes time.

Croix
Community Champion
Community Champion

Dear David~

Of course you will greive for hte way things were, and be unsettled and unhappy with the current situation. You may love your brother even now, though of course he has changed -or a hidden side of  him revealed.

 

This does not mean you do not have  barriers in place, both for emotional and financial protection. 

 

I'm not sure waht 'forgive' means, perhaps it is to no longer resent past actions, while at the same time being aware of them and acting according wiht those barriers very much in place.

 

Croix

 

Guest_9989
Community Member

I'm so sorry you're going through this. Forgiveness is hard, especially when someone hasn't been there for you during tough times. It might help to take small steps, focusing on your own healing first. Counseling and support groups can provide guidance and a safe space to talk about your feelings.

 

As for your brother, you can set boundaries to protect yourself while trying to rebuild the relationship. It's okay to communicate your needs and feelings, but also remember that healing takes time. Forgiveness doesn't mean forgetting the hurt, but finding a way to move forward for your own peace.

Well I finally heard from my brother yesterday and once again I've been disappointed. He still kept trying to convince me that the source of my mental health issues was because I was still living with mum and she belongs in a nursing home anyway (regardless of her wishes). Never mind the 2 1/2 years of cancer treatment she endured with no support from him. He then went on a 5min rant about how he doesn't give a toss what mum has done in the will, she can live with that, not him. As for asking him to reconnect us, he then ranted for another 5 minutes complaining how his life is so busy that he doesn't have time for us anymore. So once again mum is devastated at his callousness and I'm left to pick up the pieces. He knows full well that when he tells me stuff that my loyalties don't lie with him so I tell mum. Of course, this has destroyed her yet again. I swear he has no soul, along with his wife. They want mum's money, just don't want her anymore and he sees me in the way of getting it.

 

Croix
Community Champion
Community Champion

Dear David~

It is so sad to hear of your brother's behaviour. Unfortunatly their are quite a few in this world who value the wrong things in life and try to ride roughshod over others.

 

Your mum is lucky to have someone in you who is steadfast and sees things for what they are

 

Croix

therising
Valued Contributor
Valued Contributor

Hi David

 

I wish you'd had a much different response, I really do. Having mentioned the idea of disappointment being about dis-appointing our self or someone else from a particular role in life, it sounds like your brother has finally and officially disappointed himself from being the deeply caring and thoughtful person you need him to be. Unfortunately, you and your mum are left to feel such a disappointment. Even if he'd worded things differently, he still could have got his message across without it having felt so cruel and heartbreaking. Even if he'd said 'I feel mum's anxiety and depression have had a deep impact on your mental wellbeing and I stay away because I have to manage my own mental wellbeing, because I feel I just couldn't cope' that would have at least been a more thoughtful response to some degree, giving you a valid reason for him staying away so much (he doesn't have the ability to cope).

 

With the new information you have being heartbreaking, upsetting and angering, I suppose the question remains 'What appointments or roles are you going to give to your brother now?'. 'He who will not find the time to visit'? 'He who is unable to put himself in another person's shoes'? Perhaps something else.

I just see he him as a bitter, selfish, sick soul.