- Beyond Blue Forums
- Caring for myself and others
- Relationship and family issues
- Re: My older sister triggers my panic attacks.
- Subscribe to RSS Feed
- Mark Topic as New
- Mark Topic as Read
- Pin this Topic for Current User
- Follow
- Printer Friendly Page
My older sister triggers my panic attacks.
- Mark as New
- Follow Post
- Mute
- Subscribe to RSS Feed
- Permalink
- Report Post
For quite a few years I have struggled with mental health problems and so has my older sister, this has been an issue for us in the past. My older sister has minor autism and sometimes struggles with seeing things from other perspectives and not hyper fixating on what people say.
We both still live at home and so we are together a lot. I struggle with quite severe panic attacks, and have a history of minor self harm.
The problem I have is that more often than not it is when me and my older sister have an argument, or when she says something insensitive, that triggers my panic attacks. I love my older sister and we don't have a horrible relationship, but as siblings do we argue quite a bit. It is getting to the point where we are arguing too much and it is causing me very strong emotional distress. I don't know what to do because I can't stop being around her, and I don't want to hurt her who has gone through so much. But it is becoming a massive issue for me and when I have tried to talk to her about it in the past, she goes into fight or flight and starts yelling and saying I'm blaming her for my mental health issues. I don't know what to do with this situation and I really don't want to hurt my sister.
- Mark as New
- Follow Post
- Mute
- Subscribe to RSS Feed
- Permalink
- Report Post
Hi Evee
Welcome to the forum and thank you for sharing your story.
I’m sorry to hear that arguments with your sister are triggering your panic attacks. As you already know, this is a situation that ideally needs to be rectified in order to safeguard your health.
I’m wondering if you could choose not to fight with your sister? This is about changing your behaviour to set boundaries to protect yourself without emotionally withdrawing from the relationship.
There’s a couple of ways to approach this. You could talk to your sister and agree to disagree on certain topics and choose not to discuss them with her. To raise this issue with her you only have to say that the arguing “isn’t good for either of us”. (As opposed to this change being only about your mental health.)
My son and I are both very passionate about politics but hold views on different ends of the spectrum. We decided long ago (after many heated arguments) not to talk about politics—there are many other topics to discuss where we will actually enjoy the debate without getting too heated.
If you don’t think you could reach this type of agreement with your sister, you could choose to end the conversation with your sister as soon as you realise it’s heading in a challenging direction. You can say, “Let me think about what you’re saying and let’s discuss it later” and try again when things cool down. Or try saying, “this isn’t a conversation I choose to have” and change the topic or walk away.
If your sister can’t see your point of view or displays rigid thinking, you could choose to accept that that is her nature and drop the issue—rather than trying to win the argument let it go.
I also have a sister and understand it’s a complex relationship and know that arguing is to be expected. One simple approach that I adopted a long time ago was to leave at least one unkind thing unsaid each day.
If you want to chat more, please post any time.
Kind thoughts to you
- Mark as New
- Follow Post
- Mute
- Subscribe to RSS Feed
- Permalink
- Report Post
Hello and welcome to the forums and sharing your story...
I'm with Summer Rose on this one. That is, when you see the discussion begin to escalate into a argument, stop the conversation and separate from each other?
And as you would know, you cannot change the behaviour of another person. You can only change yourself.
Lastly, and this is something my psychologist told me about in regard to having difficult conversations, and that is using DEARMAN - there are videos on youtube about this. The other thing to do is rely on using "I" statements and not using "you"
I hope that some of this helps.
Listening ...
- Mark as New
- Follow Post
- Mute
- Subscribe to RSS Feed
- Permalink
- Report Post
Thank you so much I will definitely keep this in mind, that maybe it just isn’t worth having these conversations and to try focus on the positive things about our relationship. I think you are right and it’s a good idea to focus on me and not her and to try to manage the way I respond when the issues start. I really appreciate the advise.
- Mark as New
- Follow Post
- Mute
- Subscribe to RSS Feed
- Permalink
- Report Post
Hi evee
You sound like such an incredibly conscious person, who's invested in becoming even more conscious. Developing an open mind and questioning the way forward point to abilities and skills you so obviously possess. 🙂
It's definitely not always easy to keep an open mind, especially when certain people challenge us so much. I'm a gal who tries to keep in mind things like 'What is this person challenging me to do?', 'Who are they challenging me to become?' or 'How are they challenging me to develop certain aspects of myself?'. Almost impossible to consider such things when heightened emotions are in play, that's for sure.
Developing a sense of knowing when to walk away or deescelate a situation, developing a sense of wonder (in regard to where that person's coming from), a sense of boundaries, a sense of feeling the nature of a person and situation etc etc you could say is about 'coming to our senses'. While sensitivity (the ability to sense) is a gift or ability, it's definitely one that needs careful mastering. I've found, through personal experience, it also requires great levels of self understanding. 'What am I feeling/sensing? Why am I feeling/sensing it? How can I manage the volume or amount of what I'm feeling? How can I switch off from feeling or how can I raise the volume to be able to feel more? How can I manage my nervous system, one of the physical aspects of myself that I feel through? How does what I'm sensing or feeling tie into my belief systems and/or sense of identity?' are just a handful of many questions worth asking.
I've found a sense of wonder can go a long way. With my 20yo son being diagnosed with Level 1 Autism, we've learned to wonder a lot together. I tend to wonder at him, which then leads him to wonder in search of answers. We find possible reasons for why and how he experiences life in the ways he does. For example, I could wonder why he has a particular perspective when it comes to a certain situation. I may then ask him. He'll wonder and may offer 'I don't feel it in the way you do. It has no emotional charge for me. It's just very matter of fact, when it comes to how I experience or perceive it'. A fair answer that makes sense. Wondering in search of reasons can sometimes be a good way to approach a person. With me being an intense feeler/sensitive at times, my son's actually taught me how to not feel as much (in constructive ways). I regard him as one of my teachers in life. I also recognise his need to redevelop his ability to feel. He was once a deeply feeling kid, before that was bullied out of him to a degree throughout his school years. While he taught himself to emotionally switch off (for self preservation reasons), it kind of went too far, to the extreme. So, we're actually teaching each other certain skills or abilities. Sometimes it's not always obvious when you have 2 teachers in the same room together, perhaps like you and your sister. Btw, there are plenty of times where I'm led to question (in my own mind) 'Why can my sister not feel or get a sense of what she just said to me?'. Yes, I have some sister issues too, even at 55 😁. Took me many years to work out why she doesn't feel or sense things in the ways I do. For example, while she feels a sense of strength and confidence in what she may be saying to me, I can be feeling a sense of degradation. In other words, for her to feel 'up' or 'raised', I must be put down. She can't always sense that this is what she's doing. Btw, this comes from decades of her facing being put down. She likes feeling the difference between 'up' vs her feeling 'down'. To her, this feels liberating and empowering. With this in mind, I try to feel compassion, as opposed to resentment. Sisters can be quite complex, hey 😊. In all fairness, we can be quite complex too.
- Anxiety
- BB Social Zone
- Depression
- Grief and loss
- Multicultural experiences
- PTSD and trauma
- Relationship and family issues
- Sexuality and gender identity
- Staying well
- Suicidal thoughts and self-harm
- Supporting family and friends
- Treatments, health professionals, therapies
- Welcome and orientation
- Young people