- Beyond Blue Forums
- People like me
- Multicultural experiences
- Homeless man sleeping on a park bench. Is anybody ...
- Subscribe to RSS Feed
- Mark Topic as New
- Mark Topic as Read
- Pin this Topic for Current User
- Follow
- Printer Friendly Page
Homeless man sleeping on a park bench. Is anybody willing to take the extra step?
- Mark as New
- Follow Post
- Mute
- Subscribe to RSS Feed
- Permalink
- Report Post
The last week or so every morning and evening when I take the dogs for a walk in the local park, there is a homeless man who has made one of the park benches his bed.
The first time I saw his belongings; a blanket, some towels, pillow, a couple of bags with stuff and a little trolley; he wasn’t there. Just his stuff, telling a story about the man who uses these as necessities.
Initially, I didn’t pay particular attention. It’s a very common sight where I live. Not unusual to see beggars in the corners, people washing windscreens at the lights, homeless seeking some spare change at the train station, and wandering others asking for things at those enjoying their coffees and meals at the numerous cafes down the street.
Just another homeless...I kept walking.
The next few days and nights he’d be there. Sometimes asleep, other times awake, drinking or smoking or eating something. On a couple of ocassions one of the dogs will go and sniff him and his belongings. Once or twice the ball ended up under his seat so my dog would go and get it or just sit down and rest under the shade. At those times, I had to stop. Felt awkward. Didn’t want to disturb him. Wasn’t in the mood for chit chats. Something told me to ask him if he’s ok or if he needs anything - he’s been there long enough now, in the exact same spot - yet, I wanted to also respect his ‘home’, his ‘space’. This is a public park after all, but this is clearly his spot for now.
I nodded a couple of times. Here and there a reluctant, quick, momentary glimpse. Then carried on as usual.
Not sure why, but I’m reluctant to ‘intrude’. It’s his right to be there, alone, left in his own demise. It’s also a genuine concern that I feel and a sense that if I don’t do anything, would anybody else do something? Are we all thinking the same? Is anybody willing to take the extra step? And what would that mean? Should someone contact the police? I don’t want to be that person.
The man’s looks resemble a Southern Asian. Not sure if it’s customary for people of that background to live out in the open, to take breaks from whatever life they have. Or if he’s in crisis. Maybe his relationship broke down. Or he lost his job.
We are all a step away from homelessness if you think about it. It all takes a loss of income or breakdown of relationship and we could be sleeping on a park bench.
Luckily the weather still holds.
Every time I see him and not speak I feel it may be the last chance. Yet, why am I not ready?
- Mark as New
- Follow Post
- Mute
- Subscribe to RSS Feed
- Permalink
- Report Post
Hello Donte,
My suburb is a nice place with small families and young professionals, mostly, plus a few older residents from before the area was gentrified. We have a homeless shelter somewhere and so there have always been a number of homeless people who hang around the park and the shopping centre. Mostly, they are ignored. Sometimes they're given loose change.
I have never given them anything or said anything aside from good morning or hello.
For me, it's not because I don't trust what they'll do with that money or anything like that.
I just honestly don't want to be caught up in someone's sad story when I am off doing my own thing. For me, going to the shops is my time. Walking down the street, I am usually in my head trying to enjoy time off before I have to do chores or go to work.
I am sure that me taking 5 minutes of my me-time would be valued so much more than me using the 5 minutes on myself, but I want that time for myself because the 5 minutes hearing their story will affect me and make me sad. And, frankly, I just don't want to deal with that.
- Mark as New
- Follow Post
- Mute
- Subscribe to RSS Feed
- Permalink
- Report Post
Hi all,
Im the opposite since being in that position myself and coming out if it I willingly give them advice, talk to them, give them money,hugs... Etc...I know how it feels. I once slept on a mattress with a homeless man at a church...his bag was stolen when we woke up....I've been around a lot of homeless because I used to go to the help centres- salvation army etc...and I lived in a homeless shelter....for a lot of us it means the world to be helped and acknowledged since we lost it all..
- Mark as New
- Follow Post
- Mute
- Subscribe to RSS Feed
- Permalink
- Report Post
Hello James1,
I totally get that.
Perhaps partly my hesitation could relate to this also. This is my time with the dogs too, before or after work. Maybe respecting and honouring our time-off and using it for our 'charging the batteries' time is important.
Great thought. X
- Mark as New
- Follow Post
- Mute
- Subscribe to RSS Feed
- Permalink
- Report Post
That's beautiful Monkey_magic,
I remember one xmas morning I saw someone who appeared to be sleeping under a tree (in the same park), and as my dog went next to him and started wagging and playing etc I was reluctantly forced to approach him (so I can get my dog off). We started chatting and I found out he was running away from a crisis centre as he got physically assaulted there and all his money stolen by ice addicts. He was kicked out of his girlfriend's home after a break up and ended up in the Crisis centre. The violence and drugs was so terrible that he prefered to sleep under a tree in the park instead, he told me. I invited him to my place and we spent xmas day together. We ended up going to the beach for a lovely picnic. My daughter wasn't impressed and neither were my friends but it seemed the right thing to do at the time.
In hindsight, I could have placed myself and my daughter's wellbeing at risk as we could have been robbed or assaulted etc. But at the time I went with the flow not really thinking about my safety or my child's safety and without any particular safety plan in place in case things turned sour.
Nowadays I'm a bit more careful and thinking it through...hence, the hesitation I guess...
- Mark as New
- Follow Post
- Mute
- Subscribe to RSS Feed
- Permalink
- Report Post
hello donte,
yes, thank you. I know I only have a limited amount of care I can give away. others have more, and i admire them for it.
but if i'm going to do the best i can, as a whole, there are some things i just have to walk away from.
picking my battles, as it were.
I love animals and I was reading about a lady who runs a farm animal shelter. if she tried to get every abused pig and every abused horse out of the trade, she would not be able to help any of them. so she gets one, and one only. and has to pass over every other horse and pig, knowing full well that they will suffer.
So I do get frustrated when people make accusations about why I don't donate more money, more time, etc.
Only we know what level of care we can give away in a sustainable way. You and I both spend time here, and we have our animals to take care of as well as ourselves.
Nice to hear from you, and monkey_magic too (hello, keep up the good work!)
- Mark as New
- Follow Post
- Mute
- Subscribe to RSS Feed
- Permalink
- Report Post
Hello Everyone
Well you have all made me think. James, I know how you feel about the number of people you can help. Hadn't realised it until I read your posts. I can only do so much, give so much, care so much and that makes me sad. I want to help everyone and I know I cannot because of my resources, knowledge and skills. But I can do some things.
I was in the cafe in the medical centre where I saw a psychiatrist some years ago. I was thinking about what to do next and it was obvious to a couple sitting at a nearby table. As they left the woman said to me, "I can see you are trying to make a big decision. I hope it will turn out right for you. We will remember you in our prayers." To say I was startled was an understatement. They left and I was left with my thoughts. This was a small thing to do and I wonder if we miss the opportunity for small actions simply because they are apparently small.
It was small for the couple who spoke but potentially life saving for me. You see I thinking of dying because my life was dark. I think because of that small gesture of care I decided to carry on living as there were people who cared, even if only for ten seconds. Sounds like a fairy story I think but it was true. I thank that couple because I have a good life and I would have missed all that.
I suspect my story does not help much in the overall discussion but it is an action we can do. The next question is, how do we know the time required of us if we make a simple gesture? Will we be able to leave after a simple hello? Should this be a factor in making our decision?
I don't know. Perhaps others can join in and shed some light on this tough and emotive question, taking the next step. I look forward to the next post.
Mary
- Mark as New
- Follow Post
- Mute
- Subscribe to RSS Feed
- Permalink
- Report Post
HUMBLE DEEDS
The old lady shook as she counted her pennies bare
Mumbled words he couldn’t hear but he was well aware
She kept her finger in her purse praying so it would fill
Then along came the waitress to deliver that lady’s bill
And so she sat there frozen with struggles and fear
And the good Samaritan maintained his presence near
And he rose to pay for his bread and then he’d tell
“Make sure you include that ladies cup as well”
And so the story is everywhere we go
But the kind wont brag of course you wouldn’t know
To pass on a humble deed and invisible hug
Some of the poor are crying - under a rug
And what of our soldiers that keep us safe
The evil is around for goodness sake
To buy a meal even though their pockets rich
Is to walk beside them in the mud and the ditch
And the marching band plays inside that hobos mind
Is all of his past that he can ever mentally find
And he every now and then under his hat he peeps
Another stranger walks by and his will goes to sleep
There is a section we should all grow with age
Luke 10-25 the good Samaritan page
Where a dollar saved a beggar in the midst of gloom
A dollar of humanity in the form of a warm dry room
We try we struggle to spread our hearts and goodwill
We cant spread it all and the world be fulfilled
But we can try and be proud and to ourselves be fair
That together as one…we spread love and care….
Tony WK
- Mark as New
- Follow Post
- Mute
- Subscribe to RSS Feed
- Permalink
- Report Post
Not all times are the same.
Some days I feel like everyone is beautiful and deserves love. Others, I only see the ugliness in everything.
As we all have different height, weight etc that’s how we all have different internal resources to be able to cope and deal with the harsh realities.
Some times depending on our meals, rest, level of physical pain or mental anguish, stress etc we are able; and others we are not - to engage, to care, to have interest.
Perhaps it’s absolutely ok. We just have to be mindful, aware. We are our only benchmark. No one else can tell us what’s right or wrong right now and in any given moment. No one else has that authority.
If we feel we can’t be bother to care at any given point in time then clearly, that’s the right thing for us at that point.
Good on you James for having the awareness.
- Mark as New
- Follow Post
- Mute
- Subscribe to RSS Feed
- Permalink
- Report Post
I wonder if some homeless souls are indeed homeless because they are migrants and grieve for their homeland? I wonder if that is the main reason they end up homeless, that they miss their mother country?
What do you think Donte, as you have more knowledge in that area than I?
Tony WK
- Anxiety
- BB Social Zone
- Depression
- Grief and loss
- Multicultural experiences
- PTSD and trauma
- Relationship and family issues
- Sexuality and gender identity
- Staying well
- Suicidal thoughts and self-harm
- Supporting family and friends
- Treatments, health professionals, therapies
- Welcome and orientation
- Young people